Monday, August 31, 2009

Sarah's quick overview of all things wrong with Twilight

Ugh. I hate to admit to even reading it. Now that it's over, I will be using my copy to make paper roses and various other crafts that can then be sold to poor, silly fans of this tripe. In this way I both capitalize on my horrible experience and get the glee of destroying the book slowly.

I know Aubrey already covered it chapter by chapter, but after reading it I felt compelled to add my two cents. However,
there is so much wrong with this book, I could write a novel about it of comparable length to the actual thing. But I refuse to let it take up any more of my time. I pared it down to a bullet list of the things that bothered me most:

- Our plucky heroine, Isabella Swan. Oh, oh, sorry excuse me, that’s “Bella.” For the love of GOD it’s “Bella” ONLY. She is the worst female character ever. She pretends to be strong and smart. Instead, she plays the damsel in distress. She is stupid, whiny, and throws tantrums like a five year old. I hate to think any young females view her as a role model.

-Bella whines about not getting along with other kids her age. On her first day of school she can’t be bothered to remember anyone’s names or listen to anything they say. Until it is no longer convenient for Steph to refer to them as “girl from Spanish class.” Then *poof* Bella remembers.

-Bella’s one, only, single, flaw (that Steph will admit to) is her lack of balance or ability to stand still without somehow falling on her face. In an effort to endear Bella to the reader, we are reminded of this clumsiness…oh, say…. every fifth sentence? Okay, okay, we get it. She has no balance, she’s uncoordinated, can’t play sports, sucks at gym, blah blah blah. I’m sorry to tell you Steph, but a lack of balance is not a personality flaw that adds dimension to your flat character. Lack of balance is a medical condition. Maybe Bella should get her eardrums or sinuses checked for excessive fluid.

-Bella gets carried around like a baby more times than I can count (though I did count three times by three different people in one chapter). I’m sorry, I need a “heroine” with some guts, who can use her own two legs.

-The book is written from Bella’s first person perspective; however, she seems to randomly know a lot about the feelings of other characters as though the narrator were third-person omniscient. Not to mention she is often able to describe her own expression (i.e. what her eyes look like) without having to see herself in a mirror.

-Steph uses the phrase "my heart stopped," or something similar, probably 80 times in reference to Bella's reactions to Edward. To emphasize this even more, she actually wrote in a scene when Bella is hooked up to a heart monitor and her pulse literally stops when he kisses her. I nearly threw up. I would say I could not believe she actually wrote that scene in. But, sadly, I can believe it given the ridiculousness of rest of the book.

-Edward is stupid, creepy, controlling and contradictory. “Stay away from me.” “Oh, hi again, let me ask you some weird questions.” Watches her sleep? Yeah, exactly what every girl should want in a man. And once his secret is out and he is no longer so “restrained,” he’s just as flat and boring as everyone else. Except he is still creepy and controlling.

-
From what I hear about the later books, Edward is a prude and refuses to have premarital sex. Okay, fine, I'm not saying people can't wait for marriage, but seriously, wtf? I don't care if he was born in a more conservative era, he's lived through many societal changes in point of view. He lived through the 80's! But most of all, he is so concerned with chastity because premarital sex is sinful?! Um, I'm sorry, but aren't vampires already damned hell-spawn? And, considering Bella wants to be a vampire as well, why would her chastity matter any more than his?

-Steph uses this book to teach girls that getting married right out of high school at the age of 18 is the solution to waiting until marriage for sex (in other words, the sooner you get married the sooner you can lose the chastity belt). In Twilight she mentions that Bella's mom got married at 19 and that one of Jacob's sisters, who is only one year older than Bella, was married as well. And though I refuse to read the other books, I know Bella marries Edward as soon as graduation is over. The thought that these ideas are being encouraged in young girls makes me ill. Society already has enough antiquated ideas oppressing women, we don't need other women advocating early marriage (and pregnancy) over going to college, having one's own life, having a career, being strong on one's own, etc. The only thing these books will breed is a bunch of hormonal girls with overly romanticized ideas about what to expect from men, life, and relationships. And I'm sorry to have to tell them that real life will be sorely disappointing by comparison.

-Vampires sparkle in the sun (instead of, say, exploding or turning into ash like interesting vampires do). Why? I suppose they are made of some kind of stone, Steph’s favorite adjective to use in their description. Most effeminate and least appealing description ever ascribed to any vampire character.

-Vampires go to high school, blend in with humans, and hunt game animals in areas where they are overpopulated. Hmmm… Wait. Isn’t HUMAN overpopulation a larger and more threatening problem to the planet? By their reasoning, they should feed on humans after all. We obviously need a natural predator when people like Bella are allowed to survive.

-All vampires like baseball. All of them. Even the ones that don’t live amongst humans. WHAT?

-To go long distances, vampires take airplanes like everyone else, of course. Except Steph already spent a couple passages prior to these events telling the reader about their ability to run at super-human speeds over long distances in a short period to time. And yet, crowded public transportation is the way to go… Wait, aren’t they also rich, with an opulent home and ridiculous cars? Why don’t they own a private jet in that case?

-Vampires have venom. Like snakes... I’m sorry, no. Do your homework into vampire lore. It’s the drinking of their blood that turns you into one. Not venom.

-No variety in word choice, especially adjectives. Icy, cold, stone, marble, topaz, golden, Adonis, angel, angelic, seraphic. This is about the range of adjectives used to describe Edward. In 500 pages worth of book, that’s IT. Oh wait, I forgot one. Perfect. We mustn’t forget that he is perfectly perfect at perfectly everything a perfect person should be perfect at doing. Description of other things not much better.

-Too many extraneous characters. If Bella can’t be bothered to remember their names, why should the reader have to? Sure, in real daily life, one encounters many people; however, in novels, you edit down these encounters to the significant ones that actually have an impact on the story. First guy Bella meets on her first day of school? Guys who are only mentioned once and only in regard to their attendance of the beach trip? High school girl who hates Bella randomly? People who are only named ONCE in the epilogue when they attend prom?! Yeah, none of you are necessary or move the “plot” along. You’re cut from the team. The end.

-AND, last, but certainly not the least egregious crime against literature this book perpetrated, the lack of plot. First 250 pages: stupid high school “drama” and “mystery” about Edward. Page 250 to 375: Sickeningly sweet “romance” between Edward and Bella, with bad dialogue. Page 375: Real “conflict” begins. Page 450: Roughly the place “conflict” ends. Resume sickening romance with bad dialogue. Book ends in this fashion on page 498.

++++++

If those reasons weren't enough, here are some sentences that should convince anyone with a brain that this book blows chunks in a hardcore way:

Bella is a whiny five-year old: "He was so mean. It wasn't fair" (25)

"I walked alertly into the cafeteria..." (40) Really? REALLY? I don't think that's possible. Your senses can be alert. She could have "glanced around alertly." HOW. HOW do you WALK alertly?

Eddy can't make up his mind: "Will you go with me to Seattle?" followed shortly by "You really should stay away from me." (84)

Bella has a near auto-erotic scene: "I pull all my hair over my head, letting it fan out on the quilt above me, and focused again on the heat that touched my eyelids, my cheekbones, my nose, my lips, my forearms, my neck, soaked through my light shirt..." (148)

Bella perpetuates horrible female stereotypes: "I wanted nothing more than to be alone with my perpetual savior." (166)

Simile in a simile in a simile: "he was as still as if he'd been carved from the stone his skin resembled" (177) I mean, seriously? Steph couldn't think of ANY other way to describe this?

Steph’s favorite curse phrase: “holy crow” multiple times... Okay. So, you're a writer, and you're religious and anti-cursing. I have heard this many times and will repeat it here: Just because you don't curse doesn't mean the characters you are creating don't. Get some guts. "Crap" is not that bad to say.

Steph LOVES being redundantly redundant: "I quickly rubbed my hand across my cheek, and sure enough, traitor tears were there, betraying me" (190)

Maybe Eddy should brush his teeth: "His breath blew in my face, stunning me" (193)

And uh, that was about the time I stopped recording stupid sentences. They were all so bad, my mind (and hand) grew numb. Any sentence on any page is inevitably horribly written.

That's all I have to say about that.