Monday, September 19, 2011

Battlefield: Earth - As Crazy as a Nebula of Crap

Battlefield: Earth because I'm sick of Eragon already!

On the cover, Kirkus Review promises us "Tight plotting, furious action and have at 'em entertainment." I'll hold you to that, Kirkus, because the movie was anything but tightly plotted. I don't think there's a pun bad enough to describe the plot holes in that movie, but maybe the book is better... that's generally true.

The book starts off with an introduction where Hubbard goes on and on about the difference between fantasy and PURE science fiction. He seems... kind of defensive. Surely he hasn't been accused of being a hack? He even concludes with "And as an old pro I assure you that it is pure science fiction. No fantasy. Right on the rails of the genre." Ugh, that is super pretentious.

On the back cover it is revealed that the EVIL ALIEN ENEMY are called Psychlos. Did he really take the word 'psycho' and add an 'l' in it? ... That's, uh, inventive. On the back of the book it mentions the main character's name as Jonnie Goodboy Taylor. Jesus christ. The bad guys are 'Psychlos' and the good guy is 'Goodboy.' That's some complex characterization there!

The novel opens with an obviously contrived hook with John Trav - err, Terl, saying that "Man is an endangered species." Gasp! Ohnoes! I am intrigued and want to read more about this compelling storyline! Also will you take donations to that newfangled church-thing you're starting?!

Then we get a translator's note. Ugh. It's sci-fi because we translated it from an alien language! *wink wink*

Anyway, one of the other Psychlos responds to Travolta: "What in the name of diseased crap are you reading?" This is not the last time Hubbard will use 'crap' in a weird, nonsensical context. In fact, I'm anxiously waiting to read the 'craplousy' scene, but there's plenty more crap before that!

The Psychlos start arguing about Travolta wasting his time reading, blah blah blah. We learn their highly technical term for the air they breathe: breathe-gas. That's... that's like called water drink-liquid, or calling crap butt-excretions. How hard would it be to pick a real gas? Everything's being 'translated' anyway. Oh wait, that's because the crap they breathe apparently EXPLODES when hit by radiation, so Hubbard had to find a way to make a fake gas that they breathe. And proceeded to call it breathe-gas. As retarded as the word Unobtainium is, at least it's trying to sound kind of scientific. And apparently oxygen is super deadly to them because they keep calling it 'deadly stuff.' Yes, we get it. You can't breathe it. I'm sure this will be an important plot point.

Travolta-Terl begins explaining how the Psychlos destroyed Earth hundreds of years ago and is met with derision! Shocking!
"Fairy tales, fairy tales," said Char. "Every planet I ever helped gut has some butt and crap story like that."
... butt and crap story. How does that... I don't even... wtf?

Heedless of the mocking, Travolta outlines his complex plan of "I'm going to go out and catch one of those things." But, more derision! How could they?!
"You're as crazy as a nebula of crap," said Char.
Brilliant deduction there, Char. He is exactly as crazy as a nebula of crap. Exactly.

Terl leaves feeling very 'clever' for some reason. Apparently he started the rumor that he was going to catch a 'man-thing' so that no questions would get out of hand when... he starts catching man-things. Huh. Ok then. Your logic is kind of impenetrable there, Terl.

Next up, in Chapter 2, we meet our intrepid hero! Who's kind of a dick! Stay tuned!

Sunday, September 4, 2011

Junie Moon by Marjorie Kellogg, Chapter 6

Chapter 6 of this increasingly intolerable book is characterized by a continued absence of plot. Half of the chapter is about some random character whom we barely know and who serves no apparent purpose in the larger context of the book. But more on her later.

The opening line of this chapter is a fine example of Kellogg's writing ability.
The hospital at night was like a yellow pocket tied to the outside world by a stream of visitors... (43)
This sentence is interminable so I only quoted the first third of it. Yes, Kellogg is comparing the hospital setting to someone's grungy old sweat-stained pants pocket. The two things are related, aren't they? Aren't they?!?! She could have compared the hospital to a giant vomitous pile of orange marmalade oozing its way into the outside world and that would have made four and a half billion times as much sense.

And now on to this chapter's own personal protagonist, conveniently supplanting whomever those other unappealing people were. Let's introduce her, shall we?

One of the long-term patients for whom the outside world ceased to exist was Minnie. She was dying slowly, cheerfully, and without causing any real trouble. (44)
Our narrator goes on to describe how much the nurses love Minnie "because she rarely had visitors and because she had such dreadful things wrong with her" (44).  Really? I know nurses typically have dark senses of humor because they have to in order to survive in their chosen profession, but damn. I had no idea nurses were sadists who secretly delight in the creepily "cheerful" terminal illness of their patients. I'm on to you, nurses! I can just picture a group of them, a murder of nurses if you will, chattering amongst themselves about the patients who have the most things wrong with them.

"Smith in room 21B is in the late stages of syphilis! Oh, it's so delightful! I just love him because his brain doesn't work anymore."
"What about Ellison in room 35K? She has flesh-eating bacteria!!"
"Oh my god! Let's go hover over her in her death throes right now!"


The comment about the nurses loving Minnie because she "rarely has visitors" is particularly hilarious because a few paragraphs later, the narrator describes the large group of family who apparently routinely visit her. There is also this creepy bit about the male relatives who visit her that I don't want to contemplate too much:
The men were sweet and strong and would circle Minnie in their arms as if she were a pretty, young girl. That was the only time Minnie really smiled. At those times her smile was so private that her daughter looked away. (45)
 Who the hell are our main characters again? Oh right, Acid Face and Friends. They only show up for about a page and a half in this wonderfully pointless chapter to have a really dull and also pointless conversation. The following exchange which I have not been able to decipher despite repeated readings is the only thing of note in these filler pages. Warren and Arthur are talking about Farber, a nurse who has just shown up in the preceding paragraph and whom the reader knows nothing about.

"She will help us," Warren said to Arthur. "Farber always plays it cool so I won't know what she's thinking."
 "Do you?"

 "Of course!" Warren then decided it was time to speak further about Junie Moon. (46)