What has happened thus far, forty pages into this book? Some disabled people have decided to live together. That's about it. Seriously, nothing has happened. There have been a number of confusingly random flashbacks and other miscellaneous events that neither advance the plot nor contribute to our understanding of the characters. Apparently, Junie Moon is really deformed; she looked at herself in the mirror in Chapter 4 and discovered this anew, forcing the reader to think "Oh yeah, deformities, I remember those now." Kellogg must have thought her readers would be quick to forget the acid-dumping scene from about twenty pages previous. Here is my re-enactment of her thought process: "My prose is so excruciatingly awful that readers will probably have blocked this from their memory by the time they get to the next chapter. Let's dwell on it some more!!" Did you know Junie Moon is hideously deformed? Did you?!
And this brings us to Chapter 5 which consists of a flashback of Arthur, who is the one with the non-descript degenerative nerve disease. Multiple sclerosis? Lou Gehrig's disease? Trouble with tribbles infesting your spinal column? Take your pick!
Page 36 offers a paragraph that is brain-liquefyingly atrocious. Arthur is remembering his college days, when apparently students were forced to do fieldwork instead of slog through Moby Dick (which is worse, who can say?). We learn about one of Arthur's dorm roommates, a fellow called Gembie.
He and Gembie were assigned together to the vegetable fields. There corn grew, and string beans, tomatoes and melons. Potatoes and onions were in another field. Their job was to hoe the weeds, direct the streams of irrigation water, and pick off the tomato worms (36).The highlight of this paragraph is, of course, the sentence "Potatoes and onions were in another field." I can completely understand why the editor decided to leave this gem in rather than delete it. It's an elaborate metaphor for the many onion-like layers of the main characters, and how those layers are potatoey. Also, sometimes there are worms which eat the tomato from off their souls.
Don't you want to learn more about Gembie? I am sure you do. Here you go:
Arthur had not thought of Gembie in years. But he could smell him as though he had just passed by. He smelled like unsatisfied sex ... Those smells had gotten behind his eyeballs and stayed for many years (36).First off, I want to know what "unsatisfied sex" smells like. I imagine it must smell skunk-like, because it is hard to have sex when there is a skunk around. Seriously, I have no idea what on earth the author is trying to communicate here. The closest thing I can think of unsatisfied sex might smell like is drunken frat boy vomit, in which case, why not just describe Gembie as smelling like drunken frat boy vomit? I want the alcohol-laden stomach acid in my nostrils as I read, dammit!
I must also take issue with the last sentence. Smells... behind his eyes? What does that even mean?! If you want to explain how an unforgettable smell lingered with him, why not refer to an organ that is actually capable of sensing scent, rather than eyes which, as far as I am aware, have little or nothing to do with smelling? This is equivalent to saying "The taste of ambiguous cosmological theories got inside his ears and lingered for eons."
You see how "ambiguous cosmological theories" isn't a taste? Yeah, neither is "unsatisfied sex" a smell. GET AN EDITOR.
In summary, Arthur spent his college years picking worms off plants like an antebellum slave. Also there was a guy named Gembie and another guy named Umberto. The end.