Sunday, October 11, 2009

"The Castle of Otranto" by some dead guy

Since I am an English major who has to read about a thousand pages a week, I may as well share with you all some of the less-than-enjoyable stuff that I have to read for class. This is actually somewhat difficult because I like 90% of everything that I am required to read.

But just because I like it doesn't mean it doesn't also suck. An example of a truly awful book that I enjoyed reading is "The Castle of Otranto." This is a gothic novel from the late 1700s, when novels were a new literary genre and generally trashy. It's kind of like the 18th-century equivalent of "Twilight," but with more sex and violence. Yes, that's right—people in the 1700s were LESS prudish than Stephenie Meyer is today.

This book deserves to be criticized leniently, I believe, since novels were new at the time this was written, and no one quite knew how a good novel should be written. (In fact, many people who lived during this time period, such as Wordsworth, thought that all novels were stupid crap not worthy of consideration). However, I'm not going to criticize it leniently because that's no fun.

Holy jeezus, the dialogue in this book! Awkward and stilted do not begin to describe it. See for yourself:

"Talk not to me of necromancers; I tell you she must be in the castle; I will find her in spite of enchantment."

"I do not much observe pictures" (Translation: "I don't look at paintings." Apparently the plot requires that this character have a severe phobia of ever glancing at any painting ever.)

"...I hope Matilda does not think I am such a stranger to filial tenderness as riot to resent the boldness of that audacious youth, and that it is impossible for me ever to feel any affection for one who dared to lift his arm against the author of my being"

In the case of that last quote, what Isabella (the speaker) means is that she is not in love with a guy ("that audacious youth") who tried to kill her father ("the author of my being"). You'd think there would be a simpler way to say that, such as "I can't be in love with a guy who tried to kill my father." Yeah, you'd think so, but you'd be wrong.

Amusing as this bizarre dialogue is, it is not the least bizarre thing about this novel. There are also some completely random supernatural goings-on that are never explained, one of the most notable of which is a giant that apparently lives in one of the rooms of the castle. The characters are mildly alarmed about this discovery, but for the most part it's ignored and they continue on about their business. I guess the castle is huge enough that a giant living in one room isn't such a big deal.

The beginning of the novel is equally entertaining. It opens with the king's son being crushed to death by a giant helmet that falls out of the sky. Presumably, such an event would be horrifying to all the witnesses, what with the traumatizing spray of blood that would inevitably result. But the king's reaction to his son's hideous death-by-supernatural-helmet-crushing consists of: "Well, I never liked him much anyway." Even the prince's bride-to-be agrees that he was pretty mediocre. If that makes no sense to you, that's just too damned bad, because it's all the explanation you're getting!!

All in all, this is an unintentionally funny book that is worth reading if you have absolutely nothing better to do. Your time would probably be better spent vigorously scrubbing the toilet for a few hours. I rate it 12 stars!

No comments:

Post a Comment